For those of you who are thinking of replacing the old kitchen sets or simply building your kitchen collection, today we have two great choices of cooking sets from the elite brand Calphalon. We are going to talk about the lines Simply Calphalon and Select Calphalon and their great features to help you decide which one is better according to your preferences. One thing is for sure, using Calphalon sets in your kitchen is a fashionable way of life and one of these sets will definitely fulfill your needs .
Comparison of Simply Calphalon Vs Select Calphalon we will start with a comparison table that will give you an insight into the basic characteristics of these Calphalon cookware sets.
| Simply Calphalon | Select Calphalon | |
|---|---|---|
| Image |  |
 |
| Material | Aluminium | Stainless steel with aluminum base |
| Color | Black | Silver |
| Item Weight | 18.71 pounds | 22.4 pounds |
| Number of Pieces | 10 | 14 |
| Finish type | Non stick | Non stick |
| Dimensions | 21.13 x 14.25 x 10.25 inches (LxWxH) | 24 x 15.3 x 11 inches |
| Oven safe | Oven-safe up to 400 degrees F | Oven safe up to 450 degrees F |
| Dishwasher safe | Hand-wash only | yes |
| Type of handle | Silicone stay cool handles | Comfort-grip, stay-cool handles |
| Gauge | Medium gauge | Thinner |
| Glass covers | yes | yes |
| Warranty | a 10-year warranty | a 10-year warranty |
| Price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Simply Calphalon Vs Select By Calphalon
First we are going to emphasize the similarities and the things these two products have in common.
Finish type – non stick base
The first thing worth considering when buying cooking sets is whether they have a nonstick surface. With these cookwares you will feel comfortable while cooking since they won’t allow your food product to stick and they are ideal for making different sticky sauces like caramel, fondue etc. You will be able to use them for a long time without any abrasions on the interior. You can also cook without oil depending on the recipe of course. They are made of stainless steel which provides durable quality. Each one cleans with ease.
Oven safe and stay cool handles
Simply Calphalon and Select Calphalon both give you the option to cook meat on the stovetop and finish in the oven if you want to. Both of these models are oven safe (Simply Calphalon up to to 400 degrees F, and Select Calphalon up to to 450 degrees F) so your meat will be crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. Their base with an aluminum core distributes heat evenly.What is particularly interesting about the pans is that they have special handles for comfortable grip and they stay cool enough to touch them while cooking.
Glass covers
Another interesting feature that is part of these products is the tempered glass lid.
The lids are not interchangeable and fit the cookware that is applied to them, so you can be sure that there won’t be any gaps and the steam won’t “escape”. This affects the quality of the preparation since we know that, for example, vegetables cooked on steam do not lose their important ingredients easily. With this tempered glass cover you don’t have to реек to see the what is inside. They are oven safe and also keep your food warm when outsidе.
Also read: Calphalon Simply vs Calphalon Classic Pots And Pans Set
Differences between Simply Calphalon Vs Select Calphalon
Even though Simply Calphalon and Select Calphalon share common features, which are actually very important, there are some characteristics which help us tell them apart.
Dishwasher usage
The dishwasher nowadays is a very important appliance, especially for women who got used to using it on a daily basis. That is why , when we are looking for a good cooking set we count this feature too.
Select Calphalon
In this case we can point out that Select Calphalon is dishwasher safe and the advantage is that you won’t have to lose time scrubbing it. In summary, you cook fast without a lot of effort for cleaning after.
Simply Calphalon
It is not safe to put this model in the dishwasher because you might destroy the quality of the base and you should also be very careful what type of sponge you use in order not to peel off the hard anodized non-stick coating. Even though the main material is aluminium in these products they contain different layers and this model is definitely more sensitive to “rough touch” or strong detergents. However , since it is a non-stick material , a soft sponge and regular washing detergent will immediately clean the pans.
So in this category the winner is Select Calphalon.
Item weight and dimensions
Select Calphalon
As we can notice from the table above the dimensions for these items are 24 x 15.3 x 11 inches and the items weight is 22.4 pounds which means they might be heavier to be held while cooking.
Simply Calphalon
We have some different dimensions and weight when it comes to this set. It is
21.13 x 14.25 x 10.25 inches (LxWxH) and 18.71 pounds.
Number of pieces
It is good to notice that Simply Calphalon is a set of 10 pieces (Included in the set: 8″ frying pan 10″ fry pan 1-qt. sauce pan with cover 2-qt. sauce pan with cover 3-qt. saute pan with cover 6-qt. stock pot with cover)
Select Calphalon consists of 14 pieces (includes 8-in. fry pan, 10-in. fry pan, 1.5-qt. saucepan with cover, 2.5-qt. saucepan with cover, 3-qt. sauté pan with cover, 6-qt. stockpot with cover, slotted spoon, solid spoon, slotted turner, and pasta fork).
So having these special spoons and forks which will not destroy the surface of the items is a very big plus. In this case the winner is Select Calphalon.
Also read: All-Clad MC2 vs D5: Which Cookware Set is Better?
Pros and Cons
Simply Calphalon
Pros
- Hard anodized aluminum construction which provides fast and even heating.
- Silicone stay- cool handles easy to hold
- Durable, 2-layer nonstick interior which makes cleanup easy.
- The Two Nonstick Layers are PFOE-Free
- Medium gauge which makes it resistant to warping and denting the cookware.
- Even-heating cookware for best cooking results
- Tempered Glass Covers which allow you to see inside while cooking.
Cons
- Hand wash only
- Should not be washed with abrasive sponges because the non-stick coating might peel off
- Does not contain utensils
Select Calphalon
Pros
- It contains a slotted spoon, solid spoon, slotted turner, and pasta fork.
- You can use all types of utensils, such as nylon, metal, and wooden for steering.
- Aluminum bases for fast, even heating.
- The cookware is compatible with most stovetops such as gas and electric, glass and ceramic, etc.
- It is dishwasher safe and not that sensitive to stronger sponges
- The glass returns the moisture to the pan while cooking.
- Stay-cool stainless steel long handles
- Convenient measuring marks and pour spouts
Cons
- The cookware is heavy
- The exterior tends to stain and chip after some time
- Not that thick layer, might be damaged
Which Cookware Set is Better?
It’s for sure that these Calphalon space-saving cooking sets will give you great service for the money invested since Calphalon is an elite brand. In terms of their design they will perfectly fit in every kitchen. Even though Select Calphalon contains more items and it is dishwasher safe , I have to admit that the design of Simply Calphalon looks more durable since it is made of 2 layers of nonstick interior. One layer which improves adherence and the other reinforces durability. Its medium gauge gives it a sturdy construction and it has corrosion resistant exterior. With appropriate and careful use you will use this nonstick cookware for a long time and enjoy hundreds of recipes. Either way, you will be a satisfied customer. Both are good choices, by I will put the Select in my shopping cart.